2023
| Jacob Hellman | Midland University | NAIA |
| Brett Klusman | Newman University | D-II NCAA |
| Jason Kolbas | Easter Kentucky University | D-I NCAA |
2022
| Thomas Craig | Lincoln Memorial University | DII-NCAA |
| Gustav Sjoeberg | Mercer Unversity | DI-NCAA |
| Graedon Woodward | University Tennessee-Martin | DI-NCAA |
2021
| Carson Caylor | University of Houston-Victoria | NAIA |
| Daniel Gutgesell | University of Missouri-Kansas City | D-I NCAA |
| Kyle Hickey | University of Central Oklahoma | D-II NCAA |
| Grant Jabenis | University of Nebraska | D-I NCAA |
| Jakob Falk-Schollert | University of Northern Alabama | D-I NCAA |
2020
| Jesper Gullstrand | Bethune-Cookman University | D-II NCAA |
| Cade McCallum | Creighton University | D-I NCAA |
| Adam Van Raden | Austin Peay State University | D-I NCAA |
| Isaac 'Rick' Van Der Nat | Towson University | D-I NCAA |
2019
| Tom Westernberger | University of Nebraska | D-I NCAA |
| Brandt Radloff | Creighton University | D-I NCAA |
| Peder Brunnsjo | Southern Illinois Edwardsville (SIUE) | D-I NCAA |
| Clay Kucera | Colorado State University-Pueblo | D-II NCAA |
2018
| Joel Durnford | Illinois State University | D-I NCAA |
| Albert Nilsson | Southern Illinois Edwardsville (SIUE) | D-I NCAA |
| Parker McEachern | Southern Illinois Edwardsville (SIUE) | D-I NCAA |
| AJ Nolin | Presbyterian University | D-I NCAA |
2017
| Brody Boston | Presbyterian College | D-I NCAA |
| Dominic Schnepf | University of Northern Iowa | D-I NCAA |
| Ben Hadden | Kansas Wesleyan University | NAIA |
2016
| Nick Louy | Nicholls State University | D-I NCAA |
| Sam Debartolo | University of Northern Iowa | D-I NCAA |
| Alister Balcombe | Virginia Commonwealth University (VCU) | D-I NCAA |
2015
| Ross Martens | University of North Texas | D-I NCAA |
2014
| Jimmy Jaskoske | Oakland University | D-I NCAA |
| Max McGrail | University of Utah | D-I NCAA |
| Jose Pelayo | University of Utah | D-I NCAA |
2013
| Tim Jensen | University of South Dakota | D-I NCAA |
| Simon Payne | University of West Georgia | D-II NCAA |
| Caleb Malenkie | Northwestern College | NAIA |
2012
| Zach Christianson | Iowa State University | D-I NCAA |
| Wes Apple | Missouri Western State University | D-II NCAA |
| Lance Lawson | University of Nebraska Kearney | D-II NCAA |
| Keldrin Krohe | Doane College | NAIA |
| Pat Goodhue | University of the Cumberlands | NAIA |
2011
| Scott Beach | University of Nebraska - Omaha | D-I NCAA |
| Mark Stovie | University of Nebraska - Omaha | D-I NCAA |
| Nick Wittholft | Iowa Wesleyan University | D-III NCAA |
| Nathan Zimmerman | Morningside College | NAIA |
2010
| Kevin Stanek | Creighton University | D-I NCAA |
| Greg Pohlmann | Northern Illinois University | D-I NCAA |
| Tommy Wingert | Weber State University | D-I NCAA |
| John Cantril | Augustana College (SD) | D-II NCAA |
| John Matthews | Bellevue University | NAIA |
2009
| Josh Larrison | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Davis Garner | Bellevue University | NAIA |
2008
| Drew Callahan | Kansas Wesleyan University | NAIA |
| Brian Lawson | William Penn University | NAIA |
2007
| Blake Thompson | Wayne State College | D-II NCAA |
2006
| Tim Murphy | Briar Cliff University | NAIA |
