2023
| Brett Mower | Oregon State University | D-I NCAA |
| Jakason Burks | University of Central Missouri | D-II NCAA |
| Fabian Padilla | Life University | NAIA |
2022
| Trent Strong | University of Central Missouri | D-II NCAA |
| Creighton Baughman | Concordia University | NAIA |
| Nathan Rizek | Doane University | NAIA |
2021
| Isaiah Crosby | Oklahoma State University | D-I NCAA |
| Demar Campbell | University of Calgary | Canada West |
2020
| Collin Braun | University of Central Missouri | D-II NCAA |
| Daniel Leal | Grand View University | NAIA |
| John Cleristor | Life University | NAIA |
| Melvin Hernandez | Life University | NAIA |
| Noah Rutjens | Life University | NAIA |
2019
| Thomas Lisher | Arkansas-Little Rock | D-I NCAA |
| Gio Bonilla | Grand View University | NAIA |
| Gad Huseman | Concordia University | NAIA |
| Jacob Ruiz | Life University | NAIA |
2018
| D'Andre Brumfield | Colorado State University-Pueblo | D-II NCAA |
| Tell Ward | Minnesota State Moorhead | D-II NCAA |
| Cody Kingery | Wartburg College | D-III NCAA |
| Ottis Peeler | Missouri Valley College | NAIA |
2017
| Stephen Boone | Augustana University | D-II NCAA |
| Chase Clasen | Chadron State College | D-II NCAA |
| Preston Lauterbach | Colorado State University-Pueblo | D-II NCAA |
| Chase Lemons | Grand View University | NAIA |
2016
| Oscar Ramirez | Augustana University | D-II NCAA |
| Clay Stine | Drury university | D-II NCAA |
| Paul Ivy | Notre Dame College | D-II NCAA |
| Keithen Johnson | Tiffin University | D-II NCAA |
| Printice Walls | Dubuque | D-III NCAA |
| Luke Nohns | Bacone College | NAIA |
| Jhalen Flanders | Southeastern University-Lakeland | NAIA |
2015
| Chris Schleuger | University of Northern Iowa (Football) | D-I NCAA |
| Ben Fichter | Northern State University | D-II NCAA |
| Matt Walker | Lindsey Wilson College | NAIA |
| Wilfred Charbono | Morningside College | NAIA |
| Erick Carrillo | Morningside College | NAIA |
2014
| Peter Stewart | University of Northern Iowa | D-I NCAA |
| Tyler Nation | Augustana College | D-II NCAA |
| Adrian Lozano | Augustana College | D-II NCAA |
2013
| Zak Benitz | Upper Iowa University | D-II NCAA |
| Kasey Einerson | University of Wisconsin-Lacrosse | D-III NCAA |
| Austin Borne | Doane College | NAIA |
| Devin Peterson | Grand View University | NAIA |
| Seth Stender | Midland University | NAIA |
2012
| Kevin Olson | Morningside College | NAIA |
