2022-23
| Madelyn Lund | Austin Peay State University | D-1 NCAA |
| Giulia Pucharelli | University of West Georgia | D-2 NCAA |
| Jacob Beck | Pittsburg State University | D-2 NCAA |
| Mercedes Norris | Northwest Missouri State University | D-2 NCAA |
| Rey Mojica | University of West Georgia | D-2 NCAA |
2021-22
| Evan Tollinchi | University of South Florida | D-1 NCAA |
| Gabriel Griggs | Morehead State University | D-1 NCAA |
| Kyle Gaedgens | University of Central Florida | D-1 NCAA |
| Caitlin Reed | University of Northern Iowa | D-1 NCAA |
| Rylee Zais | University of South Florida | D-1 NCAA |
| Miya Bryan | Morehead State University | D-1 NCAA |
| Christopher Bueno | University of West Georgia | D-2 NCAA |
| Dylan Worthington | University of West Georgia | D-2 NCAA |
2020-21
| Kassandra Bruguera | University of Central Florida | D-1 NCAA |
| Yofer Hernandez | University of Central Florida | D-1 NCAA |
| Kortnie Getzchman | Northwest Missouri State University | D-2 NCAA |
| Madasyn Davis | Webber International University | NAIA |
| Serika Hill | Webber International University | NAIA |
| Shawnrique Smith | William Penn University | NAIA |
| Angel Haines | William Penn University | NAIA |
2019-20
| Breanna Boley | Morehead State University | D-1 NCAA |
| Taysia Dominguez | Morehead State University | D-1 NCAA |
| Evan Guth | Wilmington University | D-1 NCAA |
| Seamus O'Shea | University of Sam Houston | D-1 NCAA |
| Catherine Groom | University of Sam Houston | D-1 NCAA |
| Jenna Schuckman | University of West Georgia | D-1 NCAA |
| Taron Still | University of West Georgia | D-1 NCAA |
| Joshua Harris | University of Tennessee | D-1 NCAA |
| Michael Bassett | Grambling State University | D-1 NCAA |
2018-19
| Noah Sturgeon | Missouri State University | D-I NCAA |
| Makenzi Brown | Morehead State University | D-I NCAA |
| Micaela Hunker | University of Kansas | D-I NCAA |
2017-18
| Judge Everest Kunce | University of Central Florida | D-1 NCAA |
| Kearsten Dye | University of Central Florida | D-1 NCAA |
| Ricky Nunn | University of Kentucky | D-1 NCAA |
| Riley Chase | Morehead State University | D-1 NCAA |
| Amber Meckley | Morehead State University | D-1 NCAA |
| Alize Aninipot | University of South Florida | D-1 NCAA |
| Melody Nelson | University of South Florida | D-1 NCAA |
| Jessica Dink | Weber State University | D-II NCAA |
| Mahaylee Peterman | Northwest Missouri State | D-II NCAA |
| Kaitlyn Groft | University of West Georgia | D-II NCAA |
| Louis Brown | University of West Georgia | D-II NCAA |
2015-16
| Jenna Dunn | Iowa State University | D-I NCAA |
| DeMaurus Narcis | Sam Houston State University | D-I NCAA |
| Titus Lauderdale | Sam Houston State University | D-I NCAA |
| Jacob Cid | University of Tennessee, Knoxville | D-I NCAA |
| Trevor Wisdom | Wichita State University | D-I NCAA |
2013-14
| Matt Meyer | Iowa State University | D-I NCAA |
| Katie Rickels | Iowa State University | D-I NCAA |
| Phillip Williams | Morehead State University | D-I NCAA |
| Michelle Turner | University of Texas at San Antonio | D-I NCAA |
| Veronica Morales | Wichita State University | D-I NCAA |
| Taylor Bott | Wichita State University | D-I NCAA |
2012-13
| Corina North | Sam Houston State University | D-I NCAA |
| Raven Gau | University of Central Florida | D-I NCAA |
| Shelbie Wise | Northwest Missouri State University | D-II NCAA |
| Quintin Martin | Northwest Missouri State University | D-II NCAA |
| Spencer Bain | Northwest Missouri State University | D-II NCAA |
| Tyler Prussing | Pittsburg State University | D-II NCAA |
| Syriena Kelley | Pittsburg State University | D-II NCAA |
2011-12
| Caitlyn Sempeck | University of Nebraska - Omaha | D-I NCAA |
| Jessica Quintus | Lindenwood University | D-II NCAA |
| Annette Woolsey | Missouri Western State University | D-II NCAA |
| Shelby Montgomery | Northwest Missouri State University | D-II NCAA |
2010-11
| Brittany Crabtree | Avila University | NAIA |
2008-09
| David Carrawy (2012 NCA - NATIONAL CHAMPION) | Sam Houston State University | D-I NCAA |
| Drew Scholten | Sam Houston State University | D-I NCAA |
2005-06
| Kolay Payne | University of Iowa | D-I NCAA |
2004-05
| Kristin Grandick | University of Nebraska at Omaha | D-I NCAA |
| Jill Shadden | Avila University | NAIA |
