2024
| Matthew Alfred | Florida Atlantic University | D-I NCAA |
| Stefan Bilinac | University of Nebraska-Omaha | D-I NCAA |
| Eyifehn Forfor | California State University Northridge | D-I NCAA |
| Timothy Mason | University of South Florida | D-I NCAA |
| Jaehyuk Moon | University of New Hampshire | D-I NCAA |
| Ryusei Shimonishi | Creighton University | D-I NCAA |
| Roman Torres | Creighton University | D-I NCAA |
| Edwin Cisneros | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Alvaro Jacinto | Bellevue University | NAIA |
2023
| Junior Casillas | University of Nebraska-Omaha | D-I NCAA |
| Ibrahim Conde | University of New Hampshire | D-I NCAA |
| Jesus De Vicente | University of Illinois-Chicago | D-I NCAA |
| Marc Escuderos | University of Tulsa | D-I NCAA |
| Oskar Greven | University of Illinois-Chicago | D-I NCAA |
| Luka Nedic | University of Illinois-Chicago | D-I NCAA |
| Claudel Ngongang | Bradley University | D-I NCAA |
| Wawa Palga | University of Nebraska-Omaha | D-I NCAA |
| Diego Quintana | University of Illinois-Chicago | D-I NCAA |
| Edoardo Deglinnocenti | Saint Leo University | D-II NCAA |
| Tomle Donig | Flagler College | D-II NCAA |
| Julian Holland | Mercy College | D-II NCAA |
| Victorio Venaria | Catawba College | D-II NCAA |
| Haakon Utesch | William Penn University | NAIA |
2022
| Giorgio Probo | Creighton University | D-I NCAA |
| Gonzalo Cuevas | University of Nebraska-Omaha | D-I NCAA |
| Joel Sangwa | Akron University | D-I NCAA |
| Maruki Kawahara | Akron University | D-I NCAA |
| Moise Bombito | University of New Hampshire | D-I NCAA |
| Jiwoo Lee | University of New Hampshire | D-I NCAA |
| Carlos Santamaria | Oral Roberts University | D-I NCAA |
| Ty Harold | Concordia University | NAIA |
| Terry Harold | Concordia University | NAIA |
| Pablo Gonzalez | Briar Cliff University | NAIA |
2021
| Joel Quashie | Oral Roberts University | D-I NCAA |
| Vlad Jokic | University of Missouri-Kansas City | D-I NCAA |
| Patrick Millard | Creighton University | D-I NCAA |
2020
| Rohan Goulbourne | Toronto FC II | USL League 1 |
| Jassem Koleilat | University of New Hampshire | D-I NCAA |
| Alexander Glynn | University of Missouri-Kansas City | D-I NCAA |
| Abdi Adan | University of Nebraska-Omaha | D-I NCAA |
| Eduardo Barros Cesar Telles | University of Charleston | D-II NCAA |
2019
| Damia Viader | Union Omaha | USL League 1 |
| Fitzroy Cummings | University of Nebraska-Omaha | D-I NCAA |
| Samuel Villalta | University of the Pacific | D-I NCAA |
| Theo Le Calve | University of Tulsa | D-I NCAA |
| Nicolas Torres | Missouri State University | D-I NCAA |
| Roberto Hernandez | University of Texas-Rio Grande Valley | D-I NCAA |
| Mario Magana | University of Missouri-Kansas City | D-I NCAA |
| Fernando Zaragoza | Carson Newman University | D-II NCAA |
| Victor Alcala | Shaw University | D-II NCAA |
| Mateo Mendez Schroeder | Francis Marion University | D-II NCAA |
| Christian Dakan | Nebraska Wesleyan University | D-III NCAA |
| Emmanuel Willie | Clarke University | NAIA |
| Jan Paule | Clarke University | NAIA |
| Victor Tosi | Clarke University | NAIA |
| John Kadima | Clarke University | NAIA |
| Marksus Aramis | Clarke University | NAIA |
| Cristian Tavera | Clarke University | NAIA |
2018
| Jaaziel Thompson | St. Bonaventure University | D-I NCAA |
| Mathieu Peyreblanque | University of South Carolina Upstate | D-I NCAA |
| Liam Handerhan | Central Connecticut University | D-I NCAA |
| Daniel Bermingham | Northern Kentucky University | D-I NCAA |
| Jose Camberso | William Jewell College | D-II NCAA |
| Henry Melville | St. Joseph's College of Maine | D-III NCAA |
2017
| Jan Hoffelner | Presbyterian College / St. John's University | D-I NCAA |
| Joao Burti | Florida Gulf Coast University | D-I NCAA |
| Kwesi Allen | Drexel University | D-I NCAA |
| Mason Farnsworth | University of South Carolina Upstate | D-I NCAA |
| Solomon Constant | University of South Carolina Upstate | D-I NCAA |
| Gustavo Fernandes | Stoney Brook University / Forward Madison | D-I NCAA / USL League 1 |
| Duhaney Williams | Loyola Marymount University | D-I NCAA |
| Mathias Ferraz | University of West Florida | D-II NCAA |
| Alberto Diaz | Florida Southern College | D-II NCAA |
| Leandro Avila | Bridgeport University | D-II NCAA |
| Joseph Connolly | Hastings College | NAIA |
| Matthew Woo Ling | St Andrews FC / North East Stars / Trinidad and Tobago National Team | Malta Premier League / Trinidad and Tobago Pro League |
2016
| Gabriel Viola | Seton Hall University | D-I NCAA |
| Eric Ganime | St. Francis University (PA) / Wuppertaler SV | D-I NCAA / Regionalliga West (Germany) |
| Willy Ramirez | North Carolina State University | D-I NCAA |
| Dominik Tajak | Wright State University / MidAmerica Christian | D-I NCAA / NAIA |
| Carlos Herrera | West Texas A&M International | D-II NCAA |
| Luis Salazar | Cal State East Bay University | D-II NCAA |
| Niv Fogel | Rose State University | D-II NCAA |
| Michael Stafford | Chaminade University | D-II NCAA |
| Barema Samassekou | Waldorf University | NAIA |
| Aboubakar Tchalombo | Bellevue University | NAIA |
2015
| Edgardo Reyes | Liberty University | D-I NCAA |
| Joshua Blair | University of Incarnate Word | D-I NCAA |
| Juan Velazquez | University of New Hampshire | D-I NCAA |
| James Narke | University of Alabama - Huntsville | D-II NCAA |
| Jackson Farnsworth | Southern Virginia University | D-III NCAA |
| Mathew Diede | Southern Virginia University | D-III NCAA |
| Steve Teshima | John Brown University | NAIA |
| Alex Trent | Ottawa University | NAIA |
2014
| Jeremiah Ziaty | Indiana Purdue University - Fort Wayne | D-I NCAA |
| Jose Navarro | Saint Mary's College of California | D-I NCAA |
| Edward Whitfield | University at Albany - SUNY | D-I NCAA |
| Nick Melville | University of Cincinnati | D-I NCAA |
| Matthieu Braem | University of Loyola Chicago | D-I NCAA |
| Fazlo Alihodzic | University of Nebraska Omaha | D-I NCAA |
| Yuri Domiciano | University of New Mexico / University of Illinois Chicago | D-I NCAA / D-I NCAA |
| Kaique Fernandes | Wright State University | D-I NCAA |
| Zane Chao | Notre Dame de Namur | D-II NCAA |
| Rafael Ferreira | Central Methodist University | NAIA |
| Jarom Farnsworth | Faulkner University | NAIA |
| Akilla Arno | Lourdes University | NAIA |
2013
| Will Lukowski | Indiana University/Wright State University | D-I NCAA |
| Leo Folla | University at Albany - SUNY / Chattanooga Redwolves | D-I NCAA / USL League 1 |
| Andres Irvin | University of Nebraska Omaha | D-I NCAA |
| Greg Timmer | Western Michigan University | D-I NCAA |
| Keaton Critchlow | Alderson Broaddus | D-II NCAA |
| Elias Hatungimana | Lander | D-II NCAA |
| Robel Yemane | Montana State - Billings | D-II NCAA |
| Alan Rivera | Texas A & M International | D-II NCAA |
2012
| Danny Molina | Fort Hays State University | D-II NCAA |
| Olivier Rolland | Hawaii Pacific University | D-II NCAA |
| Pedro Vianna Augusto | Newman University | D-II NCAA |
| Humberto Estrada | Mount Marty College | NAIA |
| Marcelo Norton | St Thomas University | NAIA |
| Manny Akok | Wayland Baptist University | NAIA |
| Renato dos Anjos | Wayland Baptist University | NAIA |
2011
| Adrian Zieg | Grace University | |
| Marco Carvalho | University of Central Arkansas | D-I NCAA |
| Jaden Hoth | University of Central Arkansas | D-I NCAA |
| Beau Johnson | University of Vermont | D-I NCAA |
| Gabriel Queiroz | Faulkner University | NAIA |
| Rafael Fagiani | Faulkner University | NAIA |
| Mohammed Al-Hussein | Grand View University | NAIA |
| Ignacio Mateos | St Thomas University | NAIA |
| Thomas Spillman | University of Purdue-Calumet | NAIA |
2010
| Mohamed Salama | University of Nebraska-Omaha | D-I NCAA |
| Jake McRae | Brigham Young University - Hawaii | D-II NCAA |
| Mauricio Chaves | Georgia Southwestern State University | D-II NCAA |
| Kleesbatner Loembet Makaya | Georgia Southwestern State University | D-II NCAA |
| Craig Butcher | Ashford University | NAIA |
| Noah Archibald | John Brown University | NAIA |
| Chris Soenksen | John Brown University | NAIA |
| Leigh Veidman | UT Brownsville & Bellevue University | NAIA |
2009
| Joao Fonseca | Belmont University | D-I NCAA |
| Mark Davis | Brigham Young University-Hawaii | D-II NCAA |
| Garret Garcia | Dixie State College | D-II NCAA |
| Mackenzie Wilde | Lincoln Memorial University | D-II NCAA |
| Matt Pruett | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Josue Armijo | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Jenner White | Culver-Stockton College | NAIA |
2008
| Landon Southwick | Brigham Young University-Hawaii | D-II NCAA |
| Kendon Knowles | Colorado State University-Pueblo | D-II NCAA |
| Tim Soenksen | Concordia University | NAIA |
| Danny Aguerre | William Penn University | NAIA |
| Garrett Wood | William Penn University | NAIA |
2007
| Chantry Palmer | Dixie State College | D-II NCAA |
| Taft Fuller | Grand Canyon University | D-II NCAA |
| Dan Fischer | William Penn University | NAIA |
| Jaimie Gibbons | William Penn University | NAIA |
| Brandon Wood | William Penn University | NAIA |
2006
| Lance Fondren | Bowling Green University | D-I NCAA |
| Jon Christy | Colorado State University-Pueblo | D-II NCAA |
| Eric Anderson | Mesa State College | D-II NCAA |
| Trevor Eastman | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Rock Christenson | Midland Lutheran | NAIA |
2005
| Erik Sterrett | Drake University | D-I NCAA |
| Shawn Blymiller | Brigham Young University & BYU-Hawaii | D-II NCAA |
| Jordan Breakfield | University of Sioux Falls | NAIA |
2004
| Danny Zuckweiler | Bellevue University & Midland Lutheran | NAIA |
| Jordan Carver | Grand View College | NAIA |
