2023
| Marley Richter | Ferris State University | D-II NCAA |
| Madilyne Schlaepfer | Northwest Missouri State University | D-II NCAA |
2022
| Sam Doughty | College of St. Mary | NAIA |
| Holly Elliott | Glenville State College | D-II NCAA |
| Luisa Gibson | Costal Carolina University | D-I NCAA |
| Seira Kubo | Ferris State University | D-II NCAA |
| Kaite Schweers | Upper Iowa University | D-II NCAA |
2021
| Maya Northcutt | Savannah State | D-II NCAA |
2020
| Emily Spies | Wofford University | D-I NCAA |
| Kassy Vest | Upper Iowa University | D-II NCAA |
| Marisa Weeks | University of Sioux Falls | D-II NCAA |
2019
| Lisa Lied | Winthrop University | D-I NCAA |
2018
| Cassidy Evreniadis | University of Southern Mississippi | D-I NCAA |
| Carlota Quintana Reinaldo | Newberry College | D-II NCAA |
2017
| Sena Ersoy | Coastal Carolina University | D-I NCAA |
| Katie Irvin | Missouri Western State University | D-II NCAA |
| Shayla Murray | Northwestern College | NAIA |
2016
| Damla Bilgic | Costal Carolina University | D-I NCAA |
| Whitney Dostal | University of Northern Iowa | D-I NCAA |
| Breanna Redl | University of Nebraska-Kearney | D-II NCAA |
2015
| Maisy Turner | Texas Wesleyan University | NAIA |
2013
| Alyna Vaughan | University of South Dakota | D-I NCAA |
| Mel Buxton | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Jane Watsabaugh | College of Saint Mary's | NAIA |
| Caitlin Fieselman | Morningside College | NAIA |
2012
| Jeicy Rivas-Plata | Morningside College | NAIA |
2011
| Emily Wenstrand | University of Nebraska - Omaha | D-I NCAA |
| Ashleigh Sorensen | AIB College of Buisness | NAIA |
| Ashley Hinrichs | Valley City State University | NAIA |
2010
| Kaitie Meyer | Midland University | NAIA |
2008
| Katelyn Dingeman | Tennesse State University | D-I NCAA |
| Candace Harless | Northwestern College | NAIA |
