2023
| Tahjzha Botts | University of South Dakota | D-I NCAA |
| Ava Knoll | Baylor University | D-I NCAA |
| Olivia Kyes | Grand View University | NAIA |
| Olivia Valdez | Mount Mercy University | NAIA |
2022
| Mattilyn Reiling | Abilene Christian University | D-I NCAA |
| Tayler Floyd | Kentucky State University | D-II NCAA |
| Myla Beckstrom | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Alexis Blankenfeld | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Karlie Chonis | Midland University | NAIA |
| Karis Gifford | Briar Cliff University | NAIA |
| Jerika Koopmeiners | Midland University | NAIA |
| Kennedy Walls | Kentucky Christian University | NAIA |
2021
| Kat Bain | Oakland University | D-I NCAA |
| Brook Melnychuk | Louisiana Tech University | D-I NCAA |
| Chloe Brown | Chadron State College | D-II NCAA |
| Madeline Layman | Felician University | D-II NCAA |
| Taya Opheim | Fort Lewis College | D-II NCAA |
| Jessica Strandlund | Chadron State College | D-II NCAA |
| Emily Hatchitt | Grand View University | NAIA |
2020
| Rebecca Barnett | Alcorn State University | D-I NCAA |
| Madysen Kim | Alcorn State University | D-I NCAA |
| Julie Katz | Colorado Christian University | D-II NCAA |
| Carlie Benes | University of St. Francis | NAIA |
2019
| Tyla Lee | Lubbock Christian University | D-II NCAA |
| Sydney Reamer | Colorado Christian University | D-II NCAA |
| Alyssa Maldonado | Colorado Christian University | D-II NCAA |
| Allison O'Driscoll | Bellevue University | NAIA |
2018
| Zoe Hicks | Louisiana Tech University | D-I NCAA |
| Keelee Huff | Alcorn State University | D-I NCAA |
| Celia Valencia | West Virginia Wesleyan College | D-II NCAA |
| Brieanna Brock | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Darby Zadina | St. Andrews University | NAIA |
2017
| Jade Lee | Kennesaw State University | D-I NCAA |
| Alyx Hagen | Wayne State College | D-II NCAA |
| Patricia Sherman | Wayne State College | D-II NCAA |
| Rebecca Riley | Morningside College | NAIA |
2016
| Raylene Uribe | Bloomfield College | D-II NCAA |
| Ellie Ponce | University of La Verne | D-III NCAA |
| Ashley Caro | University of La Verne | D-III NCAA |
| Kelsey Koozer | Midland University | NAIA |
| Tracey Edwards | Morningside College | NAIA |
2015
| Dana Hieda | South Dakota State University | D-I NCAA |
| Kaitlin Buchholz | Florida Tech University | D-II NCAA |
| Jocelyn Hernandez | Cumberland University | NAIA |
| Allie Martinez | Morningside University | NAIA |
| Rachel Henks | Morningside University | NAIA |
2014
| Morgan Hoeg | Austin Peay State University | D-I NCAA |
| Michelle Trulin | Creighton University | D-I NCAA |
| KayLynn Chrisman | Colorado School of Mines | D-II NCAA |
| Aubrey Voboril | Rogers State University | D-II NCAA |
| Taryn Kelly | University of Saint Mary | NAIA |
| Ashley Schmidt | University of Saint Mary | NAIA |
| Samantha Villegas | University of Saint Mary | NAIA |
2013
| Rebekah Sanchez | Florida International University | D-I NCAA |
| KayCee Miller | South Dakota State University | D-I NCAA |
| Ashley Pokraka | Notre Dame College | D-II NCAA |
| Taylor Jonas | University of Sioux Falls | D-II NCAA |
| Jena Gonzales | Friends University | NAIA |
2012
| Daleigh Fossler | McNeese State University | D-I NCAA |
| Greta Smeins | Morehead State University | D-I NCAA |
| Kylee Polsley | Chadron State College | D-II NCAA |
| Cailin Simpson | Rogers State University | D-II NCAA |
| Breana Canova | St. Cloud State University | D-II NCAA |
| Kylee Simpson | Wayne State University | D-II NCAA |
| Jordan Kerns | Morningside University | NAIA |
2011
| Bradi Wall | University of Iowa | D-I NCAA |
| Logann Peterson | Wayne State College | D-II NCAA |
2010
| Camille Czarnecki | Stetson University | D-I NCAA |
| Angela Jay | Chadron State College | D-II NCAA |
| Stephanie Schmidt | Wayne State College | D-II NCAA |
| Kristen Martinson | Wayne State College | D-II NCAA |
| Natalie Ruechel | Wayne State College | D-II NCAA |
| Luisa Bar | St. Gregory's University | NAIA |
2009
| Toni Dance | Missouri Western State University | D-II NCAA |
| Casey Lucas | California Baptist University | NAIA |
2008
| Laura Wilcox | Indiana University - Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI) | D-I NCAA |
| Samantha Tiefenthaler | Grand Canyon University | D-II NCAA |
| Samantha Buchanan | Missouri Western State University | D-II NCAA |
| Jenna Dell | University of Nebraska-Omaha | D-II NCAA |
| Katie Lefler | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Kimber Markley | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Kelsey Meyers | Rogers State University | NAIA |
2007
| Kora Behrens | University of Central Arkansas | D-I NCAA |
| Amanda Perrott | University of Central Arkansas | D-I NCAA |
| Kady Revis | Bellevue University | NAIA |
2006
| Skye Wakefield | University of Nebraska-Kearney | D-II NCAA |
| Katie Pfannenstiel | University of Nebraska-Kearney | D-II NCAA |
| Chanel Reaves | University of Nebraska-Omaha | D-II NCAA |
| Jennifer Strohman | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Sarah Walck | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Erica Zerkle | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Danielle Abrahamson | Dickinson State University | NAIA |
2005
| Lori Huelskamp | Missouri Western State University | D-II NCAA |
| Nicole Fringer | Southwest Minnesota State University | D-II NCAA |
| Nichole Kalasky | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Danica Ritchie | Dickinson State University | NAIA |
| Dara Ritchie | Dickinson State University | NAIA |
2004
| Channon Nitz | Emporia State | D-II NCAA |
2003
| Jackie Simon | Indiana State University | D-I NCAA |
| Dallas Wilson | Southwest Minnesota State University | D-II NCAA |
| Jackie Heeren | Southwest Minnesota State University | D-II NCAA |
| Courtney Sayre | Southwest Minnesota State University | D-II NCAA |
| Amber Terry | University of South Dakota | D-II NCAA |
| Tara Buckley | Bellevue University | NAIA |
2002
| Andrea Lockett | University of Nebraska-Omaha | D-II NCAA |
2001
| Mary Shea Carpenter | St. John's University | D-I NCAA |
| Andrea Hesse | University of Nebraska-Omaha | D-II NCAA |
2000
| Nicole Garber | Creighton University | D-I NCAA |
| Sandra Owen | Peru State College | NAIA |
1999
| Missy Griese | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Laura Emmole | Grand View College | NAIA |
| Sara Gaul | Grand View College | NAIA |
1998
| Valencia Moody | University of Nebraska-Omaha | D-II NCAA |
| Angie Urosevich | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Mary Greise | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Meaghan Shea | Dana College | NAIA |
| Heather Mueller | Doane College | NAIA |
| Heather Hobbs | Doane College | NAIA |
1996
| Jaimy Echternach | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Kathy Kent | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Toshia Klinkefus | Bellevue University | NAIA |
1995
| Heidi Camenzind | Midland Lutheran College | NAIA |
| Kristine Hughes | Peru State College | NAIA |
1993
| Angie Louck | Wayne State College | D-II NCAA |
| Erin Godrey | Benedictine College | NAIA |
1992
| Brandyn Gerdes | Kansas Wesleyan University | NAIA |
1991
| Karen Wood | Missouri Western University | D-II NCAA |
