2022
| Lulu Ahl | Kent State University | D-I NCAA |
| Cherlin Antonio | Syracuse University | D-I NCAA |
| Lauren Bodily | West Virginia University | D-I NCAA |
| Melina Christodoulou | University of Akron | D-I NCAA |
| Rana Kamis | University of Idaho | D-I NCAA |
| Duru Ozkan | Murray State University | D-I NCAA |
| Elenoa Sing | Manhattan College | D-I NCAA |
| Georgia Cappelletti | Georgian Court University | D-II NCAA |
| Madisyn Havermann | Mount Mercy University | NAIA |
2021
| Yadhira Anchante | Marquette University | D-I NCAA |
| Maike Bertens | Bradley University | D-I NCAA |
| Elaina Bohnet | High Point University | D-I NCAA |
| Delaney Esterling | Prairie View A&M University | D-I NCAA |
| Aleeya Jones | Tennessee Tech University | D-I NCAA |
| Dayan Malave | Youngstown State University | D-I NCAA |
| Jexsamarie Perez | Coastal Carolina University | D-I NCAA |
| Reanne Debose | Davis & Elkins College | D-II NCAA |
| Emma Prentice | Regis University | D-II NCAA |
2020
| Iremnur Elmas | St. Francis University | D-I NCAA |
| Reka Kotorman | University of Louisiana at Layfayette | D-I NCAA |
| Leah Palensky | Dallas Baptist University | D-I NCAA |
| Lorraine Perez | Eastern Illinois University | D-I NCAA |
| Gracie Teeter | Norfolk State University | D-I NCAA |
| Emily Knight | Colorado School of Mines | D-II NCAA |
| Larissa Schneid | Mercy College | D-II NCAA |
2019
| Kortlyn Henderson | University of Houston | D-I NCAA |
| Evaggelia Athanasiadou | Saint Louis University | D-I NCAA |
| Genesis Sheridan | Colorado State University | D-I NCAA |
| Isabela Sarti | Tennessee State University | D-I NCAA |
| Bryn Stansberry | Wichita State University | D-I NCAA |
| Kelsey Havel | Northwest Missouri State University | D-II NCAA |
| Kennedy Drewis | University of Saint Mary | D-II NCAA |
| Daria De Carvalho Peixe | St. Thomas University | NAIA |
2018
| Irina Alekseeva | University of Dayton | D-I NCAA |
| Hina Pua'a | University of Arizona | D-I NCAA |
| Morgan Bossler | Winthrop University | D-I NCAA |
| Savanah Downing | University of Arkansas | D-I NCAA |
| Beatriz Girodan | University of West Alabama | D-II NCAA |
| Brooklyn McCain | Missouri Southern State University | D-II NCAA |
| Ariana Macies | Missouri Baptist University | NAIA |
2017
| Caitlyn Cooper | University of Kentucky | D-I NCAA |
| Emilia Pua'a | University of Arizona | D-I NCAA |
| Makayla Doyle | Winthrop University | D-I NCAA |
| Alison Verzani | Tennessee Tech | D-I NCAA |
| Kaci Hohenthaner | Concordia University | NAIA |
| Isabel Hinkeldey | Kansas Wesleyan University | NAIA |
2016
| Alissa Schovanec | Bradley University | D-I NCAA |
| Larissa Focosi | University at Albany | D-I NCAA |
| Olivia Wolodkewitsch | University of Virginia | D-I NCAA |
| Abby Bergsten | University of Nebraska at Omaha | D-I NCAA |
| Lauren Salerno | Hendrix College | D-III NCAA |
| Imelda Aziabou | Keiser University | NAIA |
| Makayla Aspegren | Ottawa University | NAIA |
| Kayli Grant | University of the Ozarks | NAIA |
2015
| Iva Deak | Temple University | D-I NCAA |
| Gabriella Strazzeri | Youngstown State University | D-I NCAA |
| Maile Spenser | Embry Riddle Aeronautical University | D-II NCAA |
| Taylor Liesemeyer | Minnesota State University-Moorhead | D-II NCAA |
| Maci Coffey | Doane College | NAIA |
| Rebeckah Weddle | Mid America Nazerene | NAIA |
2014
| Kathia Sanchez | Central Michigan University | D-I NCAA |
| Aly Dawson | Illinois State | D-I NCAA |
| Casey Curran | North Carolina Central University | D-I NCAA |
| Kassidy Sullivan | University of Alabama-Birmingham | D-I NCAA |
| Elly Targy | University of North Alabama | D-II NCAA |
| Winnie Cupertino | Park University | NAIA |
2013
| Sydney Nelson | Alabama-Birmingham | D-I NCAA |
| Calvineka Lockhart | Louisiana-Lafayette | D-I NCAA |
| Madison Halterman | Tennessee State | D-I NCAA |
| Tyann Thomas | Bluefield State | D-II NCAA |
| Heather Smack | Illinois-Springfield | D-II NCAA |
2012
| Sarah Kemp | Arkansas State | D-I NCAA |
| Cori Ehmen | Fresno State University | D-I NCAA |
| Erin Weis | Manhattan University | D-I NCAA |
| Dayana Acevedo | University of Texas El Paso | D-I NCAA |
| Alexa Griffith Hardy | St. Leo University | D-II NCAA |
| Daryna Liutikova | Lindsey Wilson College | NAIA |
| Zoraida Heredia | Mid America Nazerene | NAIA |
2011
| Lisa Gregerson | UW-Parkside | D-II NCAA |
2010
| Bailey Lupardus | University of South Dakota | D-I NCAA |
| Mariana Lisboa | Barry University | D-II NCAA |
| Suzy Ni Xu | Cal State East Bay | D-II NCAA |
| Tarrah Sweet | Eastern New Mexico | D-II NCAA |
| Brianna Cox | Lynn University | D-II NCAA |
| Lacey Alexander | William Penn | NAIA |
2009
| Stephanie Figueroa | University of Texas - El Paso | D-I NCAA |
| Celeste Bonter | St. Leo University | D-II NCAA |
| Andrea Rojas | Texas Women's University | D-II NCAA |
| Miranda Christian | Morningside College | NAIA |
2008
| Anna Wagner | Florida Gulf Coast | D-I NCAA |
| Michelle Kuester | Texas Tech | D-I NCAA |
| Barbara Coneicao | Texas Tech | D-I NCAA |
| Madison Hardy | University of Hawaii-Pacific | D-II NCAA |
2007
| Alicia Runge | Creighton University | D-I NCAA |
| Jodeen Rademacher | Montana State University | D-I NCAA |
| Juliana Paz | University of Michigan | D-I NCAA |
| Julia Kenealy | University of Tulsa | D-I NCAA |
| Alyssa Reich | Northern State University | D-II NCAA |
| Gabby Pfannenstiel | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Amy Slager | Peru State College | NAIA |
2006
| Kelli Fiedler | Oakland University, Michigan | D-I NCAA |
| Michaela McElroy | Missouri Western State University | D-II NCAA |
| Rachel Green | Northern Michigan University | D-II NCAA |
| Jackie Carnago | Saginaw Valley State, Michigan | D-II NCAA |
| Luciana Rapach | West Florida University | D-II NCAA |
2005
| Daviana Metti | Lees-Mcrae College, North Carolina | D-II NCAA |
2004
| Ashley Gross | University of South Dakota | D-II NCAA |
| Krystal Smith | College of Saint Mary, Omaha, NE | NAIA |
2003
| Chantal Bodkin-Clarke | George Mason University | D-I NCAA |
| Teodora Georgiva | Union University | NAIA |
2002
| Michelle West | Minnesota State University, Mankato | D-II NCAA |
| Katie Beck | University of Indianapolis | D-II NCAA |
| Liz Selzer | University of South Dakota | D-II NCAA |
| Krystal Ksiazek | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Mary Beth Bendig | Midland Lutheran College | NAIA |
| Mary Kingsley | Peru State College | NAIA |
2001
| Amanda Nelson | Wartburg College, Waverly, IA | D-III NCAA |
| Lizabeth Kirchhoff | Bellevue University | NAIA |
2000
| Michelle Blessington | Iowa State University | D-I NCAA |
| Melissa Hertzel | Black Hills State University | D-II NCAA |
| Kylee McConville | Chadron State | D-II NCAA |
| Katie Gompert | University of Indianapolis | D-II NCAA |
| Katy Sheel | Peru State College | NAIA |
| Stephanie Rutledge | St Mary College, KS | NAIA |
1999
| Holly Vogt | Lincoln Memorial University, Harrogate, TN | D-II NCAA |
| Julie Williams | Texas A&M University at Kingsville | D-II NCAA |
| Ashlee Scofield | University of North Carolina, Pembroke NC | D-II NCAA |
| Katie Ksiazek | Washburn University | D-II NCAA |
1998
| Leah Kucera | Rockhurst University, KS | D-II NCAA |
| Meaghan Shea | Dana College | NAIA |
1997
| Jodi Weatherly | Missouri Western University | D-II NCAA |
| Jodie Larson | Wayne State College | D-II NCAA |
| Sandy Brown | Peru State College | NAIA |
1996
| Michelle Stafford | Lincoln Memorial University, TN | D-II NCAA |
1995
| Jaisa Kappas | Peru State College | NAIA |
1994
| Kendra Cory | Peru State College | NAIA |
1993
| Kathy Kent | Bellevue University | NAIA |
| Erin Godfrey | Benedictine College, KS | NAIA |
1992
| Lee Dvorak | Peru State College | NAIA |
1991
| Diane Wageman | Southern Arkansas University | D-II NCAA |
1990
| Laurie Goeser | Bellevue College | NAIA |
